A “Silence of the Lambs” reference gets taken too far and Barney plans a proposal.
A copycat archer gets out of hand when he takes hostages and challenges “The Hood” to the brink of death.
Ted obsesses over borrowed-but-not-returned possessions; Robin’s dealing poorly with Barney’s rejection.
The power couple of Arrow and Huntress is short-lived due to his past with Laurel and her plans for revenge.
Ted babysits Marvin, Barney shows growth and becomes irresistible to Robin in a disappointing episode.
We meet Helena Bertinelli a.k.a Huntress, and Oliver takes a break from dad’s list to battle Helena’s father, the mob boss.
Marshall clashes with Brad and Gruber Pharmaceuticals, while the gang brags about their rebellious youths.
Nice guy Marshall gets reprimanded for excessive stamping of approval, while Barney and Robin share a sloppy kiss.
Oliver switches things up this week and fights some street scum connected with his father’s company.
Barney’s new wingman is a dog named Brover, Ted and Victoria breakup and Marshall gives sassy advice.
Ralph Lamb works to rescue a kidnapped boy while Vincent Savino deals with a Milwaukee mobster.
Savino must violently seize The Tumbleweed from other mobsters, and a maid is murdered in a hit-and-run.
Lily and Marshall conduct a game show to determine which of their friends would be the best godparent.
Ralph Lamb investigates the murder of a gold-medalist boxer while Savino hosts Chicago’s mob elite.
Barney adjusts to single life in style with Bang-toberfest, and Lily and Marshall search for a suitable nanny.
Sheriff Lamb struggles with Savino’s (Michael Chiklis) plots to kill Bob Perrin before he talks to police.
The “Autumn of Breakups” begins as Barney drafts a ridiculous pre-nup that pushes him and Quinn apart.
Michael Chiklis (“The Shield”) and Dennis Quaid (“Footloose”) star in this crime drama about Las Vegas in the ’60s.
In the season premiere, Lily and Marshall are exhausted and other relationships are simply doomed.
A drama-packed episode that positively lived up to its name